Kilted Postman...

[Chase]

Bradley,

Although I disagree with your point of view, I appreciate that you took a stand and chimed in for the nay-sayers, kudos...It's always nice to have an opposition.

Chase

[macwilkin]

Like Brad, I voted "no" in this particular poll, mostly due to my experiences as a park ranger with NPS.

Whenever I would wear my uniform on duty, I was very aware of the history and symbolism behind it. Like military uniforms, the park service has adapted and changed its uniforms over the years, yet at the end of the day, the symbolism behind it still remains.

I think part of the USPS' problems today come from the fact that has tried too hard to be like UPS/Fed Ex. with a more corporate look and logo; I know my grandfather always said that he tried to instill in his carriers that a professional look serves as a good ambassador to the taxpayer. We were certainly taught that as well in NPS, and some parks do have their rangers stand morning formation with a uniform inspection, particularly larger parks.

While I'm all for individuality, there are times when it is not appropriate. When I represented the generations of rangers who went before me, I was happy to be a part of such a group in its mission to protect the nation's natural and historic treasures.

That's not to say that this gentleman isn't doing that, but I'm not so sure the Utilikilt really is something worth fighting a battle over. The arguement that somehow this action violates "cultural diversity" really doesn't work, as the Utilikilt (as the designer himself has often stated) is not a Scottish garment.

So I'm with you Brad, and thanks to all who expressed their disagreement in an agreeable manner.

Regards,

Todd

[Detroitpete]

Bradley,

Although I disagree with your point of view, I appreciate that you took a stand and chimed in for the nay-sayers, kudos...It's always nice to have an opposition.

Chase

Great point Chase, and Bradley, good for you for speaking up. Now, I think you're 100% absolutely wrong ;-) but good for making your point especially on this topic in this forum.

I wore uniforms for the US Navy for 8 years, and yes, they did change even while I was in. I came in right after the switch back to bells and jumpers. They've changed since. Now bells and jumpers are womens dress uniforms as well. I wore Marine BDU's and the 'new' black BDU's. When I was in the Navy, with special permission, we could even wear a beard, provided it didn't interfere with the fit of our EBA's . All things change in time.

I think it was perfectly acceptable for Mr. Peterson to advocate for his positon. I also think it was understandable for the USPS to take a pass this time too.

If I were able to have a chat with the Postman in question, I'd by him a beer, encourage him to keep at it, and if so inclined take on his issue myself and do what I could do to advocate with him.