Match or not?

[JSFMACLJR]

I'd have to say every colour goes with Black Watch tartan, except white. Black looks pretty dismal though.

Your green hose will be perfect.

[davidlpope]

I think it's hard to go wrong with hose in lovat blue, lovat green, bottle green, and dark red for just about any tartan. Okay, maybe not dark red with a red-based kilt in the Ancient color scheme.

Being overly matchy looks contrived to my eye. Akin to having every bit of your clothing bear a "clan crest". Just overdone...

David

[creagdhubh]

I think it's hard to go wrong with hose in lovat blue, lovat green, bottle green, and dark red for just about any tartan. Okay, maybe not dark red with a red-based kilt in the Ancient color scheme.

Being overly matchy looks contrived to my eye. Akin to having every bit of your clothing bear a "clan crest". Just overdone...

David

Quite right David. Well said.

[Geoff Withnell]

I'd have to say every colour goes with Black Watch tartan, except white. Black looks pretty dismal though.

Your green hose will be perfect.

I think black hose go very well with Black Watch if one livens it up a bit with bright flashes or hose tops.

Geoff Withnell

[OC Richard]

The Lovat Green hose with the Black Watch kilt is a classic combination, in fact it's what is worn in the military in less formal orders of dress:



Originally the military always combined the Black Watch tartan (originally called the "government tartan") with red & white diced hose:



Much later, in the 19th century, the Black Watch switched to red & black diced hose, but the Argylls continued on with their original Government tartan kilts and red & white hose.

For a number of years I wore a quite sombre outfit consisting of Black Watch kilt, dark green Argyll jacket, and dark green hose with red flashes. The extremely dark green used for the Scottish military dress doublets is called by the military "Archer Green". Americans usually call this colour "forest green". Kilt hose in this colour are usually called "bottle green". Cars in this colour are called "British Racing Green".

But many hose colours would work well with a Black Watch kilt. Why not red hose? Anything but white or cream, for my taste.