I think your grandfather's experience is probably similar to that of many of the Highland Scots to emigrated to North America, whether it was during the 18th century or more recently. Most emigrants leave their native country because things are pretty bleak.

I suspect that the modern interest in a reconstituted "clan system" is the result of romantic notions on the part of those of us who are far, far removed from the harshness of life that lead to emigration.

For what it's worth, I've discussed this very issue with my chief, who is mindful of such matters. He's been able to direct the energy of those who "rediscover their roots" in meaningful ways which serve a greater good.

Cordially,

David