Critique invited

[Jock Scot]

Ah yes! I am sorry every one it was quite remiss of me to mention, in passing, that off topic subject of Australia not winning "The Ashes"-----again.

Note to self:- "this is a kilt forum, must keep on topic, must not mention anything about a lost cricket series ,or anything like that" Okay got it!

[Lyle1]

That is a nice turnout! I particularly like the jacket (I have one exactly like it!), and I think the tie is fine with that kilt.

[English Bloke]

Outstanding! You know that ensemble looks the business and you've only posted the pictures to show off that beautiful sporran. I've got the measure of you Sir...

Great effort. Love it.

No cricket comments from me though. Like Jock, I am aware that this is a kilt forum so it would be remiss to bring up that the Australians fared so badly this year against one of the best English cricketing sides of all time. And that the only reason you won the Perth test is 'cause the English let you. I wouldn't say anything like that... Not me! Oh no... not me. (it was a cracking contest though you have to admit. And the Rugby World Cup to come... Can't wait.)

[Downunder Kilt]

Outstanding! You know that ensemble looks the business and you've only posted the pictures to show off that beautiful sporran. I've got the measure of you Sir...

Great effort. Love it.

No cricket comments from me though. Like Jock, I am aware that this is a kilt forum so it would be remiss to bring up that the Australians fared so badly this year against one of the best English cricketing sides of all time. And that the only reason you won the Perth test is 'cause the English let you. I wouldn't say anything like that... Not me! Oh no... not me. (it was a cracking contest though you have to admit. And the Rugby World Cup to come... Can't wait.)

You've seen right through me John

As for that that game in Perth I believe you guys did let us win , to keep the interest up in the series. As the world cup is in full swing I can only hope that the final is between you and us

[robbiethepiper]

Excellent. Nice to see someone who understands complementary colours - the tasteful middle road beteen clash and matchy-matchy. Particularly like the day belt! Personally I would prefer brown shoes to go with belt/sporran but admit that's being picky and know others disagree...

[The Barry]

Yep, I've got nothing, you look great! Well done

[Highlander31]

Looks solid to me.

[lukeyrobertson]

This is a fine exchange re: matching leathers...or not. What I like is the continuum that exists between "mixing" and "matching" with regard to Highland wear. And that I think, is the gift to this forum and the best outcome one can expect when an experienced member like Downunder chooses to risk critique/feedback on something so personal. It is all a matter of tradition and personal taste (or so it seems) and that makes the conversation about Highland dress tradition really interesting and fun. And so with all that in mind, I still like the idea of brown shoes. But....

[Mike_Oettle]

Mike, that is a handsome outfit, no doubt about it.
Myself, I’m a brown shoes man (that is to say, I would wear brown shoes with a brown sporran, and black with any other), but I won’t stand in the way of Highland convention.
The tie is close enough to the Isle of Skye tartan without actually matching it (I don’t see any brown in the tie), and to me that makes it a good complement.
The balmoral is exactly the same shade as my beret tam, so of course I have to approve of that!
And Mike has a beard like mine, too.
Full marks!
All the picture needs now is an accompaniment: “Oh, I’ve just come down frae the Isle of Skye . . .”
Regards,
Mike

[Mike_Oettle]

Mike, since badges are now under discussion, would you enlighten us as to the badge on your bonnet?
The pictures don’t really show it. I presume that it is likely to be a clan crest badge, but it might be something else.
Regards,
Mike