|
-
15th December 07, 04:20 AM
#1
Looking at his Birl it looks like a "7" but with the forward movement performed as a very small movement very quickly (quicker than the eye!!) and then a very rapid draw back, with such speed his finger comes right back, I think the rapid draw backward gives it that machine gun like quality. it does appear that he only draws back his finger, Ive spoke to a few pipers that played with him and they all say the way he performed his Birl was a very unique to him, Interestingly, they all tell me that Gordon never "showboated" when playing with other pipers and would often let them take the lead, however on his new CD there is a very long recording of a Set from The Scottish Pipers Assoc Knockout Comp final in 1993 and he just effortlessly levels the opposition.
"God save the queen" is indeed the national anthem of the United Kingdon, however Flùir na h-Alba is played at football matches and national events, interstingly the tune cannot be played correctly on the bagpipe, well it can, but the c has to be played as a c natural which sounds awful against the drones, so pipers play the c which alters the melody compared to the singing version.
-
-
19th December 07, 10:23 AM
#2
 Originally Posted by beloitpiper
I just can't stand Amazing Grace. As a piper, I'm forced to play it all the time and now I hate it.
Nowadays, I really love any strathspey (that's a type of tune). A good strathspey really get my heart pumpin.
You, me and most all other pipers. As for straths, for me it's a good hornpipe or jig, but not too fast!
 Originally Posted by PiperGeorge
I do have to say that Amazing Grace  and Scotland the Brave  are down the list for me. They have powerful emotional connections, but they are overplayed and are.....well, not my favorites. (But I do understand why others do like them)
WAY over played. However, we are pipers and would all be out of a job if nobody wanted to hear us play...So, play what people want to hear we must. However, I do think that people who love pipe music should do a little research and discover the entire pipe spectrum, I mean, find out what the pipes REALLY can do!
 Originally Posted by highlander_Daz
Looking at his Birl it looks like a "7" but with the forward movement performed as a very small movement very quickly (quicker than the eye!!) and then a very rapid draw back, with such speed his finger comes right back, I think the rapid draw backward gives it that machine gun like quality. it does appear that he only draws back his finger, Ive spoke to a few pipers that played with him and they all say the way he performed his Birl was a very unique to him, Interestingly, they all tell me that Gordon never "showboated" when playing with other pipers and would often let them take the lead, however on his new CD there is a very long recording of a Set from The Scottish Pipers Assoc Knockout Comp final in 1993 and he just effortlessly levels the opposition.
Spot on. I miss Gordon dearly. I use different birls, depending on the situation. If I have a longer note before the birl, like a low A, I'll use a figure 7. Like a typical march 6/8's and such. However, if it is a fast birl, like a long birl in a jig, I use the "tap, curl" so my finger doesn't have to set up for the birl.
A lot of trad. pipers say that the figure 7 is the only correct way to do a birl. But at my level, I can't tell the difference, other than a slight difference in timing. My instructor used the "down-up slide", so it started as a figure 7, but slid right back up instead of off the chanter. I never could do that.
By the way, I think birls from B aughta be banned....
T.
-
-
15th December 07, 04:44 AM
#3
As far as Piobaireachd, my favorite is "Lament for my Brother", which is the only I've heard live. Played amazingly at a funeral, it was probably the most powerful tune I've heard. The second most would have to be Highland Cathedral played with a church organ. The organ and the bagpipes go together very well, but make sure they're tuned!
-
-
15th December 07, 05:13 AM
#4
I have found that any well played martial tune done with bagpipes tends to stir me a bit. It's just something about the sound of a group of pipers that gets me going.
We're fools whether we dance or not, so we might as well dance. - Japanese Proverb
-
-
15th December 07, 06:19 AM
#5
In order to get the blood roiling enough to make you want to pick a fight with and Englishman then have a pint after, you really should listen to or better yet watch Albannach. They're a "tribal" group out of Scotland that usually make the Highland Games tours during the summer. Their latest album Eye of the Storm I thought was their best yet. They have a version of The Gael that just makes you want to knock someone out. I use it when I'm working out. 
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eXTbxnePVs
-
-
15th December 07, 09:35 AM
#6
 Originally Posted by Drillagent
In order to get the blood roiling enough to make you want to pick a fight with and Englishman then have a pint after, you really should listen to or better yet watch Albannach. They're a "tribal" group out of Scotland that usually make the Highland Games tours during the summer. Their latest album Eye of the Storm I thought was their best yet. They have a version of The Gael that just makes you want to knock someone out. I use it when I'm working out.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eXTbxnePVs
Albannach was at the games in Estes Park, CO, this year and yes they do get you moving. The age range of fans was amazing to me, kids in the single digits all the way up to 70's plus. And everyone was moved by their music.
BTW, thanks for the youtube link.
-
-
15th December 07, 11:11 AM
#7
"Amazing Grace" and "Scotland the Brave" are wonderful, and I like them only on the pipes, but I have to say for me, "Coming Home" has always been a favorite.
-
-
15th December 07, 02:06 PM
#8
 Originally Posted by Drillagent
In order to get the blood roiling enough to make you want to pick a fight with and Englishman then have a pint after, you really should listen to or better yet watch Albannach. They're a "tribal" group out of Scotland that usually make the Highland Games tours during the summer. Their latest album Eye of the Storm I thought was their best yet. They have a version of The Gael that just makes you want to knock someone out. I use it when I'm working out.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eXTbxnePVs
"As long as war is regarded as wicked, it will always have its fascination. When it is looked upon as vulgar, it will cease to be popular."
Oscar Wilde
-
-
19th December 07, 10:29 AM
#9
 Originally Posted by Drillagent
In order to get the blood roiling enough to make you want to pick a fight with and Englishman then have a pint after, you really should listen to or better yet watch Albannach. They're a "tribal" group out of Scotland that usually make the Highland Games tours during the summer. Their latest album Eye of the Storm I thought was their best yet. They have a version of The Gael that just makes you want to knock someone out. I use it when I'm working out.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4eXTbxnePVs
They are way cool. It's funny, tho, it take 5 drummies to keep up with ONE piper....! :o
T.
-
-
24th February 08, 11:38 PM
#10
[B]~~Rory "Indiana" Gentry[/B]
[I]The Right Reverend Rory the Dissolute of Leg Over Wallop; Baron Rory the Carnivorous of Steakly St. Cattleton; Grand Duke Rory the Imposing of Much Bottom[/I]
-
Similar Threads
-
By Riverkilt in forum General Kilt Talk
Replies: 31
Last Post: 9th September 07, 10:39 AM
-
By sporranlegionaire in forum DIY Showroom
Replies: 9
Last Post: 25th June 07, 01:31 PM
-
By Dreadbelly in forum Miscellaneous Forum
Replies: 44
Last Post: 5th April 07, 05:37 PM
-
By Riverkilt in forum General Kilt Talk
Replies: 0
Last Post: 2nd April 05, 10:22 PM
Posting Permissions
- You may not post new threads
- You may not post replies
- You may not post attachments
- You may not edit your posts
-
Forum Rules
|
|
Bookmarks