Quote Originally Posted by Rawlinson View Post
Well, the answer seems to be fairly unanimous. Thank you all.

Now to choose a color or tartan.... I'm leaning towards saffron (my ancestry is about 90% Irish), but if someone can find something in Clan Barclay dress muted tartan, you would forever be my hero (I have yet to find a tartan that I think would look better with a Polamalu jersey).

Out of curiosity, how do Stillwater Heavyweight kilts compare?
I don't have one of their heavyweights, but their acryllic kilts seem well made, and their shipping is lightning fast. They have both green and saffron available in heavyweight, both with a 'shadow tartan' pattern, i.e self coloured but with a raised pattern. I have a saffron acryllic 'standard' of theirs, but even their wool ones are well within your budget.