No synthetic fur is going to match the softness of beave, so for texture the beaver one is the clear winner.

However I would vote for the Lesser Acryla beast one. I think it is a better looking sporran that would go with more outfits than the beaver one. I am not a fan of gold/brass in my kilt accessories. The gold highlights of the beaver sporran are too formal for most occasions (actually to me they screams "trying too hard" to be fancy). The simple silver of the first sporran is classy, which I'll take any day over "fancy".

Cheers

Jamie