Contemporary Sgian Dubh

[Geoff Withnell]

Would one of you fine gentleman that own one of these knives kindly post a full review? I would be very interested to hear more about them, and how it has held up for you, esp. the composite model. Many thanks!

Gladly.
The steel version I rarely wear as a sgian. Between the almost 8" overall length and the thickness of the sheath, it seems a bit large for that purpose. I have done so, tho. The belt clip on the sheath grips you garter and does make for a secure carry. That said, the knife itself is wonderful. The blade is VERY sharp and tough, and I have cut all manner of things with it, and it is still as sharp as the day I got it, two years ago. The handle has a good feel and is quite non-slip. This is a real working tool, made in a traditional style from modern materials.

The ceramic composite does not come with a sheath, nor does ColdSteel carry one. It is the same overall length as the steel (7-3/4") but is much thiner and of course lighter. With a sheath I made from a piece of scrap leather, it works fine as a sgian. While the edge is not nearly as sharp as the steel, it is sharp enough for most purposes. I have cut rope, heavy cardboard, and a six foot submarine sandwich into individual portions with it. The latter at a group picnic when no one had brought a sharp knife in the utensils. It seems to be surprisingly tough. The ColdSteel website has video of their line of this kinives that is quite impressive. Can't beat it for $11.99.

I also have a knife from them called a SuperEdge, which is a nice little number that I also sometimes wear, because the blade is short enough that I can carry it into places one cannot carry a weapon. I have carried it into the Pentagon (not concealed, with security's knowledge)! The link is:

http://www.coldsteel.com/superedge.html

Hope this helps. If you buy one, wear it in good health, and may you never have to draw it in fear or anger.

Geoff Withnell