Is this Traditional?

[wvpiper]

While the attire depicted in the painting is undoubtedly historically accurate, it is not traditional Highland Dress...simply because it has no currency today.

I don't follow. In fact, I don't understand the 'splitting of hairs' that many of you are engaging in.
I agree with CajunScot that the kilts thought of traditional today, the 8yd knife pleated, is based on the kilts worn in the military post Proscription.